Wednesday, August 03, 2016


“Disaffected Dudes”

How can a community college reach underemployed men in their twenties and thirties?

This group -- Josh Wyner called them “disaffected dudes,” which I’ve decided to steal -- comes back to college at far lower rates than women of the same age.  Some of that may be the perverse side effect of the wage gap; if men without degrees make more money than women without degrees, then the opportunity cost of men returning to school is higher.  (If he makes 40k and she makes 20k, then sending her to school means forgoing 20k; sending him would mean forgoing 40k.)  But anecdotally, that seems like only a small part of it.

Part of it, I assume, is programming.  When I was at DeVry, the student body was about ⅔ male, and mostly older.  That seemed to be a function of advertising and the programs offered, though it probably also became self-perpetuating at a certain point.  Tressie McMillan Cottom later told me that it was an outlier, and that in fact, for-profits as a sector skewed female.  That makes the question even harder.

I’m raising the question not to discount the economic issues women face, of course.  I’m raising it because as a sector, we seem really bad at answering it.  

The sociological treatments I’ve seen of gender and wages suggest that people making secure adult wages with benefits are likelier marriage prospects, and likelier to provide stable homes for children.  At a really basic level, that makes sense; it’s easier to be your better self when the wolf isn’t at the door.  If we want stable families -- however defined -- good jobs are helpful.

In the mid-twentieth century, lots of “disaffected dudes” could find good jobs in the unionized blue collar sector.  The blue-collar aristocracy offered the underpinnings for stable family and community life.  My grandfather did that.  He dropped out of the ninth grade, eventually finding unionized work with Detroit Edison as a lineman.  On that salary, he was able to send two kids to college.  Mom even talked him into sending her to the University of Michigan, which was a relatively progressive gesture in the early 1960’s.  Between his good job and generous public support for higher education, they could do it.  

Jobs like that are scarcer now.  Brookdale has a program with JCP&L, the local electric utility, to train people for jobs like that; it routinely attracts several hundred applicants for about 25 positions.  Nice work if you can get it, but it’s hard to get.  The fact that hundreds of applicants show up for that particular program suggests that they’re out there, and if you find the right hook, they’re reachable.  We just haven’t found the right hook often enough.

Reaching the disaffected dudes is hard, precisely because they’re disaffected.  Churches are often female-dominated and tend to skew older.  Outside of the public sector, unions aren’t what they used to be.  Even popular culture has fragmented to the point that it can be harder to ensure that you reach people.  In the 90’s, DeVry could advertise on Ricki Lake and get her viewers.  (It did.  Class discussions required etiquette lessons.)  With the proliferation of screen options, it’s much harder to get large numbers in one place than it used to be.  

Has anyone out there done a consistently good job of attracting underemployed guys in their 20’s and 30’s?  If so, how did you do it?  

We held a Donald Trump rally with a lot of guns and beer and gave out Roofies for them to use at parties.
Our Advanced Manufacturing program is heavily male. Two semesters. Pretty much guaranteed job. And something that someone with a criminal record can still get into.
nice blog too informative. looking and reading your points its so impressive. doing more blog like this. i really appreciated doing like this.
Informatica Training Institute in Chennai
Great blog..You have clearly explained about the concept..Step by step explanation is too good to understand..Its very useful for me to understand..Keep on sharing..
Hadoop training in chennai
This blog is having the general information. Got a creative work and this is very different one. We have to develop our creativity mind. This blog helps for this.
Thank you for this blog. this is very interesting and useful.
SEO Training in Chennai
your Blog is really important and thus it is really useful and i got more information from your blog which is nice and implementing.

Software Testing Training in Chennai
Provides great information about the concept.It helps an individual to gain knowledge on new techniques.Keep on giving this type of information.
Dot net Training in Chennai
There are lots of information about latest technology and how to get trained in them, like this have spread around the web, but this is a unique one according to me. The strategy you have updated here will make me to get trained in future technologies. By the way you are running a great blog. Thanks for sharing this.
Hadoop training in Chennai

I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.

SEO Training in Chennai
Even if you don't trust online services - a few words about and you will probably make up your minds. This company employs only those writers who can do original and high quality texts, besides, they are professionals in hundred of education areas, so you may be sure in brilliant results.
Hello! Being a student isn't a simple job, as we may think. Because nowadays students are very lazy, but have a lot of tasks and responsibilities. Luckily, there is a solution - - real experts here can create any type of academic paper for students from all over the world at any suitable time!
nice blog too informative. looking and reading your points its so impressive. doing more blog like this. i really appreciated doing like this.
Java Training in Chennai

this is really too useful and have more ideas from yours. keep sharing many techniques. eagerly waiting for your new blog and useful information. keep doing more.

Java Training in Chennai

I read this content really awesome.You provided another one great article.I hope this information may change my business carrier.I can remember these things whenever taking the decision

Best Informatica Training institute in chennai


I read this content really awesome.You provided another one great article.I hope this information may change my business carrier.I can remember these things whenever taking the decision.

Informatica Training in chennai
Best comment: Trump, guns, beer, Roofies. That's the way to get these man.

“ETS (etradeservices)Packers and Movers Bangalore has been a top-rated moving company that not only offers high-quality services to satisfy customer's”
movers and packers rates in pune
movers and packers in hyderabad
packers and movers bangalore

Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?