Thursday, June 11, 2015


Friday Fragments

The MDRC just published a paper demonstrating what many of us on the ground have known for years: year-round financial aid makes a positive difference in both speed and likelihood of degree completion.

It makes sense.  “Summer melt” isn’t confined to the high school years.  January intersession can be a tremendous boon to students, since it allows extended focus on one thing.  (It’s especially good for certain lab classes, since long periods allow for more ambitious experiments.)  

The beauty of year-round financial aid is that it’s conceptually simple, and it works in concert with the completion agenda.  When students who are on a roll have to stop out simply because the aid clock won’t restart for several months, life gets more chances to get in the way.  

Year-round aid existed for a hot minute, but it came and went so quickly, and with so little fanfare, that many colleges didn’t get a chance to take full advantage.  Now that completion is very much front-and-center, bringing it back would make sense.  In 2015, it’s hard to argue with a straight face that national higher education policy should take the agrarian calendar as sacrosanct.  Let’s recognize reality, and realize the gains from continuity.


If you haven’t yet seen the Hechinger Report’s piece on college in Norway, it’s worth checking out, even though it buries its most interesting part in the middle.

Briefly, Norway does an admirable - enviable -- job of getting economic barriers to college out of the way.  College is free to students, much like high school is here.  But Norway is much less polarized than we are, so you don’t have the massive disparities among colleges that we have among high schools.  Students even receive cost-of-living stipends.

Even with all of that, though, college attendance varies strongly with income.  

At one level, that seems like an argument for giving up on efforts to expand access.  If access has natural limits, and we’re almost there now, what’s the point?

But the piece makes two points that make the fatalistic conclusion shaky.

First, Norwegian higher education doesn’t do much in the way of “student support.”  You’re an adult; you sink or swim on your own.  We do much more to try to help students avoid sinking.  It may be that one cancels out the other, at least in part.

Second, though -- and to me, this is the smoking gun -- in Norway, it’s still relatively easy to make a decent living in a blue-collar occupation.  College is free, yes, but it’s also truly optional.  

If we want to talk intelligently about higher education, we can’t separate it from the larger political economy.  If we do, we’ll miss the point.


Farewell, Ornette Coleman.  

He was an unusual one, but a real talent.  Anyone who would entitle his album “The Shape of Jazz to Come” is not messing around.

His music was a distinct blend of lyrical and abstract.  I remember the first time I heard his “Dancing In Your Head,” and thinking it was either the smartest party music or the hottest chamber music I’d ever heard.  He was a huge influence on Pat Metheny, among others, even though the affinities weren’t immediately obvious.  Nothing about him was immediately obvious.

Others will write about “Lonely Woman,” and that’s fine.  But for me, it’s “Feet Music.”  Even at his funkiest, nobody else sounded like him.   


Friday, June 12 is my last day at HCC.  Thanks to everyone who made it possible to look back over seven years with justifiable pride.  Now it’s time to heed the siren call of Jersey...

To the webmaster,

Please accept our apologies for involving your website in potentially damaging SEO practices.
The third party we hired to manage our SEO utilized backlinks in ways that violated Google’s Terms of Service.
Our site,, has been penalized accordingly and we must pursue the removal of all known backlinks to restore our search ranking.
In order to do so, we require that you delete the backlinks hosted on your own site.
They can be found here:

By doing this, you will enable us to progress in the overturning of the penalty so that we may resume serving our customers.
Thank you for all your help.

I'm curious where the whole "Norway has better options for Blue Collar work than the US" comes from? Coverage of health care? Their booming oil industry? (I guess we could think of North Dakota as being analogous, or gas exploration in PA/NY.)
Year-round aid just makes so much sense. It is very hard to find a job in the summer that will pay for two semesters of full-time (15 credits) classes, and impossible to work and carry that load. But 12+12+6 gets you to the same place with a bit of slack for jobs and "life getting in the way", while 12+12+9 is doable and you end up ahead. Some even flip that around. Students who work in the service sector are often needed for more hours during the "school year" than in the summer, so they want to load up in the summer.

On Norway, I've seen some detailed articles explaining why it and other Scandinavian countries are far more entrepreneurial than the US, and the answer is health care plus the retirement system. I haven't seen anything about blue collar jobs, but that might result from a tax system that encourages a pretty flat payroll. Like that US company in the news recently, where all of the employees make $50k, one company from Norway that I saw profiled had a CEO who said he just didn't need all that extra pay. Profits went to the employees.

Amen on Ornette Coleman. I was listening to "The Shape of Jazz to Come" and "Free Jazz" (with a young Freddie Hubbard) tonight. The double quartet in stereo in Free Jazz is just amazing to listen to. Thanks for the tip on "Dancing in Your Head".

Interesting comment about Pat Metheny. A friend posted a link to a fairly recent video of Ornette Coleman in concert, and the next stuff in the video playlist is all by Pat Metheny!
Good luck in your new position. I hope it doesn't interfere with your blogging.
I thought the point of summers-off financial aid was to keep the riffraff out of college.
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?